The Garden Network - social networking community - find, meet, chat and talk to gardening industry professionals...
Search:   
Home|Search|About|Jobs|Careers|Training|Industry News Signup|Login|Invite|Help Area
garden designers, landscapers, contractors, gardeners, college students, tree surgeons, grounds maintenance...
Blogs|Photos|Profiles|Events|Groups|Videos|Polls|Marketplace Why Join?|Gardeners|Homeowners|Students|Business

Charging by %age
10:45 AM on 23 June 2008
Filed under: My business

I have a question!

I have long been looking at charging more in the style of landscape architects for larger projects: ie, charging my fee as a percentage of total completion sum, rather than as a lump sum payable on completion of various stages of works. I think that for longer projects it gives more flexibility: you can just work away on everything that the client needs doing without constantly recalculating whether each bit of work is already paid for or included in a previous sum, and having to constantly send new invoices to the client for, I don't know, renegotiating a tender action or sourcing a particular stone finish or something. I'd much rather just accept all these works as my responsibility knowing I'm being paid for all of them from the start. And I think it actually pays more in the long run too!

I've just had a proposal for a large and probably quite long-term garden project accepted at 7.5% of total certificated completion sum. I've had a good deposit, but the question is this: at which trigger points should I require further payments? I'm obviously requiring payment in advance of the final contract sum, which I don't know yet, and the completion certificate should just make up the final difference - but I can't wait until the end of the project to suddenly get paid thousands, my cash flow won't stand that. So, at what points do I require payment, and how much do I require?

Has anyone had any exerience of clients trying to avoid payment on this principle, too? It would be relatively easy for a client to disguise the size of his payments to the contractor, thus reducing my fee. I'm only acting as the client's agent to the contractor, not as project manager, so I won't necessarily see all the bills. I think that trust between the designer and the client is a basic necessity but I can understand the temptation. Are there any tricks of the trade to avoid this? Is it just a matter of really good communication with the contractor?

Any thoughts and experiences gratefully received!

 

Mark

 


Back to markengland's Blog     Report Inappropriate Content    

Comments (1)
bob1947 - 1:07 PM on 23 June 2008  [ message ]
Hi Mark.

I cannot provide an answer from a garden design perspective but can offer some thoughts related to various software projects in which I have been involved where delivery can be 'fluid'.

I assume that there is a cap on the cost of the project and you will know the completion figure and a delivery date. This being so, the client will expect a completed delivery that covers all of the items contained within the 'functional specification and should not be too fussed about the amount of work completed at stages throughout the project providing he sees progress at certain times. Lets face it if after 3 months he saw a single trench, he might feel that progress is too slow!

You will require funding throughout the project so perhaps go for fixed sums at regular intervals, perhaps monthly and to show the level of progress, is it possible to give a percentage of completed work from the spec, for example:

Brick wall 50%
Hedge planted 25%
And so on

In this way you can be flexible in the percentages without having to spend time on going into great detail of completed work and preparing invoices.

Alternatively, can you break down the tasks to a ‘man day’ level whereby building a wall might take two men 10 days to complete thus 20 man days. You can then estimate the number of days left to complete a task and use this as a progress schedule.

I have to say with software, there are cases where the client will try to delay payment even though software has been delivered. In this case it is usually necessary for the account manager i.e. you in this case to step in and make the case. It is of paramount importance that the account manager and the client have a good relationship as there will be times when there is a delayed or non-delivery but you still need payment! In your case it seems also that you need to know more about the project managers charts are saying.

Your note says that you are looking at a 7.5% return on completion – should you look for a higher deposit to spread over the intervening months?

Not sure if that all helps but hope so.
Regards
Bob

© The Garden Network website design © MacArthur

The Garden Network (TGN) is a gardening community: garden design, landscaping, maintenance, college students, contractors, professionals, beginners and amateurs!

TGN is a garden industry forum described as "...a networking website that looks set to become the 'Facebook' of the Horticulture world." by Horticulture Week, April 2008.

homeowner garden designers landscapers tree students gardeners amateur nurseries contracts setting up club profile finding friends messages blog photos groups events settings privacy business advice upgrade results profiles images social email conduct sgd gardening chat classifieds find hadlow writtle discount wcoh myerscough pershore recommendations code terms contact lawns beginners growing veg styles garden software landscapers garden design organic mk head gardener gardening courses garden designers plant database garden designers